Offspring,
silverchair Leave Controversial Songs Off Setlists
SonicNet
June 7, 1999
Offspring, silverchair Leave Controversial Songs Off Setlists Absent from rock
bands' sets at Hard Rock RockFest '99 are tunes whose lyrics
were cited for violence by religious and civic protesters.
Correspondent Lang Whitaker reports:
HAMPTON, Ga. -- Rather than taking an in-your-face posture with local protesters,
the Offspring and silverchair chose not to play songs deemed
dangerously violent by a group of civic and religious leaders
Saturday at the Hard Rock RockFest '99.
A group calling itself Be Level-headed -- a play on the title of an Offspring
song, Beheaded (RealAudio excerpt), which the group
said it found particularly offensive -- formed in May to seek
cancellation of Saturday's concert. Certain songs by artists
on the bill, including the Offspring, silverchair and Better
Than Ezra, could inspire young concert-goers to commit acts
of violence, the organization claimed.
One of the songs targeted was silverchair's Suicidal Dream . "[The
song] is about teenage suicide," silverchair singer Daniel
Johns said before his band took the stage midway through the
all-day show at Atlanta Motor Speedway. "It's not telling
people to go out and do it. It's just about what people must
go through when they're going to commit suicide during their
teenage years."
Nonetheless, the Australian rock group didn't play that song or Israel's
Son, another song from silverchair's 1995 debut, Frogstomp,
whose lyrics came under fire by Be Level-headed and which
venue officials asked them not to play.
"[The protest] doesn't bother us at all," Johns said. "They
are just trying to get as much publicity for their cause as
possible so they can make more money for their organized religion,
I guess."
The Offspring, who also were targeted for the song Cool to Hate,
declined to talk to reporters Saturday.
A few blocks away, fewer than 100 people milled around, praying and talking,
as part of a protest against the all-day rock show. Christian
music played over a stereo system.
Protest organizers cited two recent high-school shootings -- a deadly incident
in Littleton, Colo., that claimed 15 victims and one a month
later in Conyers, Ga., in which six students were wounded
-- as examples of the effect rock lyrics could have on teenagers.
Brad Bernall, whose daughter Cassie was killed in Littleton, sent a letter
to be read at the event. "Lyrics that promote death,
despair and degradation are harmful to your soul," the
letter read. "You will find this to be more true as your
life goes on."
Youth minister Tim Bach, 26, helped organize the protest at North Forty
Park in Griffin. "This has been a good day for us to
come together," he said. "We got Coca-Cola and Kroger
to make some donations to a few charities."
Meanwhile, 127,000 fans were partying at the RockFest, which also included
Live, Third Eye Blind, Sugar Ray, the Mighty Mighty Bosstones,
Everlast, Eve 6, Better Than Ezra and Marvelous 3. There was
also a 40-foot-high Ferris wheel, a Sony PlayStation bus and
other attractions.
While the fans sweated, doffed their clothes and sought relief at one of
the speedway's several first-aid stations, silverchair played
an intense set, marked by Johns' brooding, growling vocal
style.
The Offspring, who headlined the 9 a.m. to 11 p.m. event, included their
hits Pretty Fly (for a White Guy) and Why Don't
You Get a Job in their energetic set.
Sugar Ray singer Mark McGrath made several efforts to dive into the throng
of people. After his set, he explained, "We've always
tried to involve the fans in our show, so I figured what the
hell. Besides, I'm pretty drunk right now."
Backstage, several performers condemned the protest. "People try to
read messages into the music, and that's really going too
far," Everlast said shortly before he took the stage.
"It's crazy that people are protesting, man," Mighty Mighty Bosstones
singer Dicky Barrett said. "To protest the song lyrics,
that's really getting picky, like you're just looking for
someone to blame. It's just music, dude. Take it for what
it's worth."
One Offspring fan, a 16-year-old from Stockbridge, Ga., who gave his name
as Pyscho Drummer 2000, said the bands were entitled to their
freedom. "They can do whatever the f--- they want because
it's legal," he said. "The bands are not the ones
to blame; it's the ones killing them motherf---ers."